Origins of a Species-Killer?

In case you missed this earlier this week, there was an intriguing detective science story that, if correct, has yielded remarkable news about the past of our planet, and of course, us. From an AP story by Richard Ingham (via Yahoo):

asteroid collision event simulationThe extinction of the dinosaurs 65 million years ago can be traced to a collision between two monster rocks in the asteroid belt nearly 100 million years earlier, scientists report on Wednesday.

The smash drove a giant sliver of rock into Earth’s path, eventually causing the climate-changing impact that ended the reign of the dinosaurs and enabled the rise of mammals — including, eventually, us.

(Image above: Simulation images (AFP/HO/Don Davis) of the asteroid collision event, and the resulting extinction collision event on earth, and the collision with the moon.)

The scientists are William Bottke, David Vokrouhlicky and David Nesvorny, working at the Southwest Research Institute in Colorado. They traced the rock to a collision event that took place in the inner parts of the asteroid belt somewhere about between 140-190 million years ago, producing the family of fragments collectively called the Baptistinas, the largest being Baptistina 298. Over time, some of the fragments found their way out of the asteroid belt, and created a shower of rocks in the inner solar system. 65 million years ago, the scientist believe, one of them hit the earth, creating the famous event that changed the earth.

The trace of the great event, called the Cretaceous/Tertiary Mass Extinction, can be seen today in the shape of a 180-km (112-mile) -diameter impact crater at modern-day Chicxulub, in Mexico’s Yucatan peninsula.

The trio of researchers — William Bottke, David Vokrouhlicky and David Nesvorny of Southwest Research Institute in Colorado — took their theory a stage further and checked out sediment samples from the Chicxulub site.

They found traces of a mineral called carbonaceous chondrite, which is only found in a tiny minority of meteorites, as the earthly remains of plummeting asteroids are called. Most asteroids can be excluded from the Chicxulub event, but not Baptistina-era ones, they contend.

Putting simulation and chemical evidence together, the team rule out theories that a comet was to blame rather than an asteroid, and say there is a “more than 90 percent” probability that the killer rock was a refugee from the Baptistina family.

The investigators also put a 70-percent probability that a four-km (2.5-mile) Baptistina asteroid hit the Moon some around 108 million years ago, forming the 85-km (52-mile) crater Tycho.

And an interesting note:

The peak of “Baptistina bombardment” was probably around 100 million years ago but is not over yet, the paper cautions.

Many of the asteroids that skim dangerously close to Earth today owe their orbits to that great collision in the deep past, according to the authors.

-cvj

Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Origins of a Species-Killer?

  1. Clifford says:

    What about it? Can you point to the research? Maybe also some discussion of it?

    Cheers,

    -cvj

  2. Lab Lemming says:

    So what about the Princeton research that puts the impact 300,000 years before the extinction?

  3. Amara says:

    The Yarkovsky effect. For more, see Bottke’s papers web site above and look for his 2006 Ann. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 34 review article.

  4. Clifford says:

    I think this is mentioned in the article. There was a mechanism mentioned, if I recall correctly.

    -cvj

  5. toby says:

    when objects collide within the asteroid belt, how do they make their way to earth in 75-125 million years?
    wouldn’t they need some impulse pointing roughly towards the earth’s orbit? i suspect a comet might still be involved (if indirectly).

  6. Amara says:

    That’s funny.. The last time I was at SwRI-Boulder in April, I had several conversations with Bill Bottke, but he didn’t say anything about this fantastic work! I was so sleep-deprived at the time, however, it’s possible that he did, and I didn’t register it…

    I see from Bill Bottke’s papers web site, that this story was embargoed, but it is not any more, so I found the links to the papers (now, if I could only find time to read it…). Here they are, in the current Nature issue:
    (unfortunately, these are available to Nature subscribers only.. perhaps Bill will make them available at his web site soon)

    Editorial,
    News and Views
    and Bottke and Vokrouhlicky and Nesvorny paper

    Enjoy…

  7. “The trace of the great event, called the Cretaceous/Tertiary Mass Extinction, can be seen today in the shape of a 180-km (112-mile) -diameter impact crater at modern-day Chicxulub, in Mexico’s Yucatan peninsula.”

    Is this (almost) certain now? I remember reading about it as a kid, then it being debunked, restated, debunked… So I don’t follow anymore 🙂

  8. Yvette says:

    Wow. Just thinking of those orbital mechanics calculations make my head hurt.